When Secretary of State Hillary Clinton gets to Istanbul on Friday, senators and their staffs will be watching closely to see if she moves the ball forward on an agreement to station U.S. missile defense radar there, an agreement many Republicans oppose.

"We write with concern over recent reports that the administration may be nearing completion of a bilateral agreement with the Turkish Government to base a U.S. AN/TPY-2 (X-Band) radar in Turkey," wrote Sens. Jon Kyl (R-AZ) and Mark Kirk (R-IL) in a July 12 letter to Clinton and Defense Secretary Leon Panetta obtained by The Cable.

The senators want the radar to be based in either Georgia or Azerbaijan, which they argue are better locations for defending against a missile attack from Iran. But more broadly, they are concerned that Ankara will place a number of onerous restrictions on the radar, such as demanding that no data be shared with Israel. The senators have also accused Turkey of violating U.S. sanctions against Iran, which they said calls into question their reliability as a partner in organizing a missile defense system aimed at Tehran.

In a May 12 meeting with Principal Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy James Miller, a senior Missile Defense Agency representative told the senators that "a forward-deployed X-Band radar in either Georgia or Armenia would have significant advantages for the missile defense of the United States," the senator wrote.

The senators wrote a May 16 letter to Miller asking for a complete analysis of alternative sites, but they said that they have yet to receive any response.

Kyl and Kirk also suggested that they will attempt to thwart any missile defense agreement with Turkey unless the Turks agree to share data with Israel, stop violating Iran sanctions laws, and keep the system under the control of U.S. personnel.

For both the Obama administration and the George W. Bush administration preceding it, international missile defense deployment has always been based on both security and diplomatic considerations. The Bush administration plan to place missile defense infrastructure in Poland and the Czech Republic was a key aspect of strengthening relationships with those two countries, until the Obama administration scuttled it.

A senior GOP Senate aide explained the insider rationale to The Cable.

"Secretary Clinton knows the Congress well and she knows that support for a radar in Turkey will quickly collapse on both sides of the aisle if the Turks get any control over its operational activity or veto rights over sharing data with Israel," the aide said. "Given Turkey's strained relationship with Israel and non-compliance with U.S. sanctions against Iran, there's a strong feeling that if the Turks have any operational control over the radar we can be sure it will be turned off the day we need it most."

 

LOGICAL123

12:14 AM ET

July 14, 2011

A total waste of money

No matter where these radar systems are placed, they will be a total waste of money. So, let Secretary Clinton not sign the agreement. Azerbaijan and Georgia are puny countries, where Iran could easily dismantle the systems. This is all based on Iranophobia generated by neo-cons and Israeli die-hards. With a $14 trillion debt, where do they find the money for these useless radar systems. The idea that Iran is going to attack Europe is so preposterous that only stupid Americans would believe it.

 

NICOLAS19

9:48 AM ET

July 14, 2011

lets get this straight

The senators oppose the plan because there might be a chance that Turkey might object to sharing the data with Israel... come on, who is building, who is paying for this expensive system, the US or the Israelis? If they want missile defense, buy one, but I don't see why should the data sharing with Israel a central issue in the signing of that bilateral agreement.

 

KATE POSPISIL

8:20 PM ET

August 5, 2011

Let Secretary Clinton not

Let Secretary Clinton not sign the agreement. Azerbaijan and Georgia are puny countries, where Iran could easily dismantle the systems. This is all based on Iranophobia generated by neo-cons and Israeli die-hards. With a $14 trillion debt, sázkové tipy where do they find the money for these useless radar systems. The idea that Iran is going to attack Europe is so preposterous that only stupid Americans would believe it.

 

JERICA DELBUSTO

1:37 AM ET

August 12, 2011

Don’t sign Turkish missile defense agreement

Turkey is discussing investing a large amount of money into a theater missile defense capability. This could be a multi-billion dollar contract and has attracted interest from a variety of companies across the world. The reason the nation needs this system is being debated as while they do border Iran they have decent relations with that country.

Reported by jenna jameson

 

HEATH SLAWSON

4:35 AM ET

August 12, 2011

Senators to Clinton: Don’t sign Turkish missile defense agreemen

"Regarding the missile defense issue,
we believe in a fair deal which will be based on mutual security interests," Lavrov said,
adding that this topic is the only disputable point between Russia and NATO.During the NATO-Russia Council in Sochi on July 4,
the military bloc refused to provide legally binding guarantees that its missiles would not be directed against Russia, which Moscow says is the only way to prevent a new arms race.NATO also refused to agree to Russia's proposal for a so-called sector missile defense network in Europe.
The alliance insists on establishing two independent systems that exchange information.

For more information:riley steele

 

John Hudson reports on national security and foreign policy from the Pentagon to Foggy Bottom, the White House to Embassy Row, for The Cable.

Enter your email address to get The Cable delivered to your inbox each night:

Delivered by FeedBurner