Tuesday, June 7, 2011 - 6:39 PM
UPDATE: Ecclestone now says the race is a no-go due to the opposition of the racing teams. "Of course it's not on," the BBC quotes him saying.
On Friday, the Federation Internationale de l'Automobile, the governing body for the world of motor sports, announced its decision to return the Bahrain Grand Prix to the island Gulf nation, which has been rocked by unrest, brutal human rights abuses, and a deepening sectarian divide since protests broke out on Feb. 14.
In making its decision, the FIA sent a "fact-finding mission" to Bahrain in late May to determine whether it would be safe to hold the race, which was canceled earlier this year amid the violence. According to Formula 1 chief Bernie Ecclestone, quoted in the Guardian, "The FIA sent people out there to check on the situation, they came back and reported everything is fine."
The report, a copy of which was provided to FP by the New York-based human rights group Avaaz, was signed by FIA Vice President Carlos Gracia, who traveled to Bahrain on May 30 and May 31 along with an assistant, Carlos Abella.
It appears to be a complete whitewash.
According to the report, Gracia and Abella met with several government officials, including Minister of Culture Mai bint Mohammed al-Khalifa, Interior Minister Rashid bin Abdullah al-Khalifa, Public Security Chief Maj. Gen. Tariq bin Dana, Bahrain International Circuit Chairman Zayed R. al-Zayani, and BIC CEO Salman bin Eissa al-Khalifa -- and seem to have accepted their views uncritically.
They also met with Tariq al-Saffar of the pro-grovernment National Institute of Human Rights, who was appointed in 2010 by King Hamad. (Saffar is also managing director of advertising firm Fortune Promoseven, which lists the F1 Grand Prix as a client.)
Gracia and Abella did dine with several unnamed foreign business leaders -- a dinner arranged by their government host -- but met with zero members of the opposition or with independent rights groups, and did not tour Shiite neighborhoods that have reportedly been under siege for weeks, though they did visit a shopping mall.
Nonetheless, they concluded, "Life in Bahrain is completely normal again" -- an observation at odds with copious reporting on the state of fear that has gripped the country since Saudi troops intervened in late March.
Other questionable assertions: "Security is guaranteed" ... "visitor figures have returned to the same level -- and are even increasing -- when compared against figures in previous years" ... "atmosphere of total calm and stability" ... "the presence of military forces was limited to a few, certain, strategic points."
In perhaps their most ludicrous claim, the fact-finders found "NO indication of any problems or reason why Bahrain's F1 Grand Prix should not return to the 2011 Calendar."
No problems?
Human Rights Watch Deputy Director Tom Porteous, in a May 26 letter to FIA chairman Jean Todt, urged the FIA to consider the government's harsh crackdown in making its decision.
"The government's violent suppression of all protests in mid-March, in which some two dozen persons were killed, mostly protesters or bystanders at the hands of security forces, has featured large-scale arbitrary arrests, protracted incommunicado detention, and credible allegations of torture or ill-treatment of persons in custody," Porteous wrote.
That advice seems to have been ignored.
"Formula 1 wanted to be told that everything is fine, and that's the answer they got," said Rutgers University assistant professor Toby Jones, an expert on Bahrain.
The Bahraini regime has presented the return of the Grand Prix as a major victory, a stamp of approval from an international community that has largely condemned the crackdown.
But holding the race may have been a miscalculation, warned Jones, "because it gives the protesters a date to rally around."
The race is now scheduled for October 30, but a change of heart by Ecclestone and growing opposition from racing teams could see it canceled yet again.
President Obama was due to meet Bahrain's crown prince on Tuesday.
There are many Bahrainis who are against F1 to be held in Bahrain because of the human rights violation by the government and they expect the international community to raise these issues instead of supporting the government saying there is nothing going on in Bahrain now and that life is returned back to normal when many doctors. journalists and students are still in jail and people are arrested on almost daily basis for showing their objection to the government suppression.
My concern is that since the time is set, we will witness more protests around that time and the government will deal with these protests in a very violent way inside the villages and stop them from going out on the main road to prove to the world that everything is under control and Bahrain is safe.
So you decide, but remember the blood of these people will be on your hands forever F1!
Entertainment in the Middle East
I have found it disturbing for quite some that that in the midst of tyranny sporting events and entertainers continue to follow the almighty dollar in spite of how it might look.
Mr Bahrain, it is nice to know that the general population is not supporting these events, but similar to North America it is unlikely to stop the majority of people from supporting these large draws.
The only reason an F1 race should be shut down is security. If the government can guarantee the security of the event and the supporters (which I'm not sure), I see no reason to shut it down.
Show me a country in the calendar with immaculate human rights records. Does the human rights watch stand up against powerful countries? No way, ever.
- There was a race in China, that is definitely not a human rights model country. Did you hear a murmur?
- There will be a race in the US, a country murdering hundreds of thousands of civilians in three wars. Is the blood of all those people on the hands of F1, hm, MRBAHRAIN?
Oh dear, what a mess this situation has become. I cannot possible see how such a large sporting even can go ahead here if only for security reasons alone. This is a frivolous multi-million pound sporting event and as usual the thoughts of lining pockets are being considered above the thoughts of safety and sanity on part of the patrons who wish to attend.
Eccelstone is not doing any favours to the situation either. Only last week he was on TV stating how the GP would obviously go ahead, after pulling it out once and now hes back to changing his mind. Eccelstone has all the charisma (and honesty!) of a salesman at times, instructing what (he thinks) should and shouldn't happen based on how he sees his and his friends bank balance benefiting!
Its the same erratic way Eccelstone runs QPR, except at least he has a little interest in Formula 1 past the financial side. I think at the end of the day if the racing teams, who themselves are spending hundreds of thousands on each race do not wish to take part its a moot point. Review the situation in 6 months for next seasons calendar and see where it has concluded (if anywhere at all)
Eccelstone canceled the race.
Carlos Gracia is an international idiot !
U.S. sadministration and Human Rights in the M.E.
Why blame F1 when the U.S President is meeting the crowm Prince at the Whiye House? Just goes to show mention Iran and you commit NO wrong in the U.S administration's eyes! Yet the same administration has the audacity to blame Ghaddadfi for humam Rights vioations in Libya.
The latst news is that medical staff at a particular hospital have been arrested and cgarged to court probably for daring to treat the citizens of Bahrain maimed by the Saudi Invasion Force armed with American weapons!
(6)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE