Wednesday, January 26, 2011 - 2:06 PM
A top State Department official in Tunis pledged full American support for the Tunisian drive to hold free elections on Wednesday, but also sought to distance the U.S. position on Tunisia from other mass protests in the region, such as the ongoing unrest in Egypt.
"What happened in Tunisia strikes me as uniquely Tunisian. That the events that took place here over the past few weeks derive from particularly Tunisian grievances, from Tunisian circumstances by the Tunisian people," Assistant Secretary of State for Near East Affairs Jeffrey Feltman said at a press conference.
He called for free and fair elections in Tunisia and pledged both American and international support to set them up.
"The United States stands with the people of Tunisia. This is an exciting and unprecedented moment in Tunisia's history with great challenges but also great opportunities for the Tunisian people to chart their own course," he said.
Feltman allowed that there are some fundamental similarities with regard to human rights.
"The challenges that are faced here are in some cases shared. And we think governments everywhere should be finding ways to permit peaceful assembly, freedom of speech, freedom of the media in order to give people a say in how they are governed and to give them a stake in the future," he said.
Feltman's remarks echo Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's latest statement, which also calls on the Egyptian government to stop harassing protesters, but doesn't call on the Egyptian government to let them participate in a real election process.
"It is important that the government listens to the concerns of those demonstrating and respects rights of freedom of assembly and expression," she said. "Openness, transparency and political freedom are important tenets of stability. We urge the government and demonstrators to seek a peaceful way forward."
The Obama administration's support for Tunisians' right to self determination was on display during last night's State of the Union speech by President Obama, a speech in which he didn't mention Egypt at all.
"We saw that same desire to be free in Tunisia, where the will of the people proved more powerful than the writ of a dictator. And tonight, let us be clear: the United States of America stands with the people of Tunisia, and supports the democratic aspirations of all people," said Obama.
The White House issued a statement from Press Secretary Robert Gibbs at about 11:30 PM, after the president's speech had concluded, expressing U.S. support of Egyptians right to peaceful assembly, but without any call for free and fair elections.
"The Egyptian government has an important opportunity to be responsive to the aspirations of the Egyptian people, and pursue political, economic and social reforms that can improve their lives and help Egypt prosper. The United States is committed to working with Egypt and the Egyptian people to advance these goals," the statement read.
During a Wednesday morning roundtable, State Department Policy Planning Director Anne Marie Slaughter explained the seeming disparity by noting that there was consistency in the sense that both stances include a respect for "universal values."
"That means we are strongly supportive of the Tunisians in the effort to achieve democracy, it also means we are not imposing our values on countries around the world," she said.
The New America Foundation's Steve Clemons said that the George W. Bush administration, despite that it outwardly advocated for democratic change in the Arab world, might have taken a similar stance as the Obama administration has on Egypt.
"The notion that we're somehow in the streets with every potential freedom movement would be a mistake in foreign policy," he said. "If this administration was out there calling for regime change in Egypt, I think that would be a huge mistake."
EXPLORE:ARAB WORLD, MIDDLE EAST, DEMOCRACY, DEVELOPMENT, DIPLOMACY, EGYPT, ELECTIONS, HUMAN RIGHTS, ISLAM, OBAMA ADMINISTRATION, STATE OF THE UNION, U.S. CONGRESS, U.S. FOREIGN POLICY
Treason to the American Values, nothing less
These remarks are outright betrayal to everything the American people stand for, and it is a travesty that he is part of the government. He actually has the nerve to explicitly say that "we" are not in support of every freedom movement out there? Well he then speaks of some alien planet or perhaps China. Mobarak's regime has a worse human rights and democratic record, has commited more atrocities against his populace and covered up more corruption than Saddam Hussein. This is outright hypocricy to turn our backs on 80 million Egyptians in their plight and day of revolution from dictatorship, just because the dictator happens to be a convenient servant to our interests. Without a doubt this is exactly what makes the World hate us and would no doubt increase radical attacks against us and isolate us from the civilized World we so claim to lead.
But who cares? As long as we are pumping the black gold for our suv's and our military contractors can sell more armored vehicles and teargas grenades back to Mr. Mobarak and his ilk.
This is making me sick.
I agree with others in their commentaries:
Feltman's wishful thinking of somebody that has an interested party and is an not of American enough in wishing other people to be under a Dictatorship and not a Democracy.
Speaks poorly of Mr. Feltman and of this Administration.
The State Department has placed the FOX to watch over the hens. ja ja ja
John Hudson reports on national security and foreign policy from the Pentagon to Foggy Bottom, the White House to Embassy Row, for The Cable.
(4)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE